second round's on me is a classic

[Biertje?]

I think it's a good album, but no classic.
And deffinatly not better then The eminem show. Though much better than the Massacre.

[DOPE]

oh shit oh shit oh shit

i aint heard the shit yet , when i hear shit i will surely get back to this shit and say shit

but what Asp said was good shit


PS: those motherfuckers who think this album is like TES can suck my dick

[,-,'-{Bar}-',-,]

man you gotta hear ti tis great :d defiantly deserved more sales still not classic though

[Hadez]

Its not a classic. I had imagined that it might be a classic before it was realeased, but its just not IMO since i didnt like all the songs.


A classic.

1*stands the test of time
2*All tracks are good, meaning wen ur listning through the album u dont skip
3*The albums reviews dont get to mixed up, wen a hip hop fan hears a classic he knowsits a classic, classics get ultimate aknowledgement.. for example: i dare u to say "ready to die" isnt a classic
4*(although this might be neglected at some cases but in most this is important too) - It has to sound different and be of some importance to the hip hop movement, in other words it gots to be unique.
5*(another optional factor) Has to be universal: a non hip hop fan should be able to somwhat like the sound of the album, a good example for this kind of album is "the eminem show".

SROM

1*Not yet, but it might gain more relevance with time in future.
2*I know it might be my opinion but most of the people i know that heard it, couldnt say that they loved all the tracks, some jus sounded repetative and although good technically .. not so good as an outcome.
3* id give it time till the album spreads before talking bout other peoples views since i dont know them.
4*With all due respect to O, his album aint sounded no different from an average hip hop album the uniqueness of his style was born on "cheers".
5*Im not a non-hip hop fan, so ur gonna have to ask someone that isnt, but in my opinion this aint universal material.

when u said all tracks are good does that inclue skits? becuz on the marshall mathers lp i skipped the skit with the blow job crap.