by _Hawk_ » Nov 9th, '11, 18:28
Struggling to see how my opinion is face-palm worthy?
Instead, let me be specific and explain why (something you both fail to do)
OK, the first line: 'I can almost taste it' sounds like some cheesy advert for a new food-product or flavoured lip-gloss.
'Wake up behind these trenches, you run around defences' is extremely cheesy as well. Having Em use a hook from a third party to big himself up (the chrous is ambigiuous, but it can easily be seen as such) annoys me. There's nothing creatively innovative about it. To me, the hook is extremely below par. And the lines themselves belittle the rest of the chorus for me.
Now let me say this, I think the verses are pretty good. Nothing terrible about them, but the hook and the beat sound extremely machined; the hook sounds poppy: hence my opinion expressed previously. Nothing to discriminate against here at all, I don't think. As I said, it's an opinion.
But the focus of this topic was on the hook, and you took my post completely out of context.
The hook is one of the best on the album? I might actually agree with that; I think the majority of the hooks on Recovery are plain awful. But that's just my opinion.
Sorry if I upset you.
"Oh, he'll give us what we need.
It may not be what we want."