The Marshall Mathers LP VS. The Eminem Show

[Emshady2]

Sing for the moment, Without me , Till I Colapse, cleanin out my closet ,white amierca
Vs Stan , The Way I am , The real slim shady , Kill you .

Greatest songs on the album goes to The Eminem Show

And the Rest of the songs goes to The Eminem Show again


So the best album is The Eminem Show by far

[Raids-God]

Sing for the moment, Without me , Till I Colapse, cleanin out my closet ,white amierca
Vs Stan , The Way I am , The real slim shady , Kill you .

Greatest songs on the album goes to The Eminem Show

And the Rest of the songs goes to The Eminem Show again


So the best album is The Eminem Show by far

Your forgetting ... Criminal and im back. 2 of Ems best tracks !!!!!

[Emshady2]

Sing for the moment, Without me , Till I Colapse, cleanin out my closet ,white amierca
Vs Stan , The Way I am , The real slim shady , Kill you .

Greatest songs on the album goes to The Eminem Show

And the Rest of the songs goes to The Eminem Show again


So the best album is The Eminem Show by far

Your forgetting ... Criminal and im back. 2 of Ems best tracks !!!!!

I took the songs I like the most on the albums. And i think they are the best. Almost everysong is good on those albums , But Drips isn't so good

[Slim's Shady]

Sing for the moment, Without me , Till I Colapse, cleanin out my closet ,white amierca
Vs Stan , The Way I am , The real slim shady , Kill you .

Greatest songs on the album goes to The Eminem Show

And the Rest of the songs goes to The Eminem Show again


So the best album is The Eminem Show by far

By far? wat.

[macdaddy019967]

best album ever created

[theJFKshow]

[NicoleEM]

TES sounds slightly better then MMLP to me

[bigandy]

MMLP

[Emadyville]

The Eminem Show

MMLP is dope, but TES just has too many amazing songs

[Emshady2]

I don't understand! The Eminem Show is one of the best, IF not The best hip hop album of all time!

MMLP Isn't so far behind- MY OPINION

TES 10/10
MMLP 9.5/10

[katha]

I couldn't decide. MMLP is outstanding alone for the sheer bravado of it. "So you were offended by my last album and want to censor me? You ain't seen offensive yet. Now go ahead and try to stop me." It's dealing with the controversy around him in a smart, witty and creative way and throwing it back at the hypocritical "OMG think of the childrenz!?!" brigade. The quality of songs like Kim, Stan and Criminal is insane. But yes, some of the features drag it down a bit.

TES has one or two clunkers as well. White America, Sing for the Moment and Till I Collapse are again out of this world brilliant though. IMO it has a bit more variety musically, but loses some of MMLP's coherence for it. The gloating that they couldn't stop his first two albums and the attacks on the government (shortly after 9/11 when everyone daring to say anything vaguely critical about Bush was deemed "unpatriotic") are awesome. As is the more thoughtful and self-critical approach to some of the songwriting.

Yeah, I would say it's about even. Both are mindblowingly great.

[VenomBlackViper]

MMLP & SSLP are tied as his best albums for me, Slim Shady & angry Eminem > thoughful, deep Eminem
I still bump the fuck outta TES though.

[Rindain1]

Lose Yourself beats both of them!

[xxTrigger1989xx]

Holy shit, his two best albums

TES is my favorite album ever, so my choice is obvious...

Encore

[mdemaz]

MMLP...