The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

My Recovery Review

Here you can review anything related to Slim Shady

My Recovery Review

Postby CLV22798 » Sep 11th, '10, 08:23

I wanted to review Recovery the minute it I heard it in June, but I wanted to let the album sink in a little bit before I took my time in reviewing Recovery. I have been an Eminem fan since he came out with the Slim Shady LP. I believe that before listening to Recovery, he had 3 classic albums under his name. Which would be: Slim Shady LP, Marshall Mathers LP, The Eminem Show. Encore was just a disappointment, and Relapse was just not the type of comeback I was hoping he would have. No matter how I felt about Relapse, I was still looking forward to his next album alot. Which was supposed to be Relapse 2, but turned in to Recovery. After listening to Recovery, the conclusion I came up with was that I think it is his best album to date. After a the whole summer of listening to the album, my mindset hasn't changed one bit. Here's my track by track analysis:


1. Cold Wind Blows
Great way to start out Recovery, I think this is the best opener he's ever had for an album. It's right up there with White America as the best track he's done to start an album. Love the beat that Just Blaze was able to bring out, and Eminem just flowed perfect with it.
9/10


2. Talkin 2 Myself
This was actually the first song I heard when Recovery first leaked. Originally, I wanted to hear the album from start to finish when it came out. But, I couldn't find Cold Wind Blows so I just heard this song first. I loved this song from the moment I heard it. As much as I love Not Afraid, I still think this would have been a better lead single for the album. It pretty much explained what was going through his mind when he was addicted to drugs, and in the last verse promising the fans he's back. Loved the beat and Eminem's lyrics and flow went great with it.
10/10


3. On Fire
This song kind of threw me off when I first heard it. Based on the title, I thought it would be a song in which he would use the fast flow he had been using on features of other people's songs. This song has a good beat to it, but I wish he would have used a faster flow on this song.
7/10


4. Won't Back Down
When I first heard he was doing a song with Pink, I didn't know what to expect. Based on the title, I thought it would be a motivational type song similar to Not Afraid. I was surprised to find out I was wrong, but I really liked the song when I first heard it. This is the flow that I wanted to hear on the song before. I still think this should have been the 2nd single instead of LTWYL. This song to me sounds like it was just meant to blow up on the radio.
8/10


5. W.T.P.
At first, I thought this was the weakest song in Recovery. It took awhile for this song to grow on me. Now, I have come to like this song for what it is. I wouldn't be surprised to see this song be a future single for Recovery. Just like WBD, this song sounds like it was meant to blow up on the radio
7/10


6. Going Through Changes
This is in my top 5 favorite songs on Recovery, and definitely one of my favorite songs of all time. Everything about this song was great: the beat, lyrics, flow, etc. I also love the fact that it's the only song in Recovery that has 4 verses. It makes it feel like it was just a special song. I hope that this song becomes a future single, with a music video to go with it. I think if Eminem were to make a video for this song, it would take the song to another level. With him showing how exactly he was like when he was all drugged out. and then at the end, rising above adversity and overcoming the challenges that were thrown his way.
10/10


7. Not Afraid
When I first heard this song, my thought was that it completely destroyed anything that was on Relapse and Encore. The last thing I wanted to hear was a joke type of first single. I wanted to hear something meaningful and worthwhile. and Eminem didn't disappoint with Not Afraid. There's only one negative thing I could say about this song, which is that the beat sucked. I wish someone other than Boi-1da would have produced this song. I would have liked to see what Kanye would have done with a song like that. I would have liked to see Eminem rap over a Jesus Walks type beat. That would have been epic.
9/10


8. Seduction
After Boi-1da disappointed me with Not Afraid, he redeems himself with Seduction. This time he comes up with a good beat, to back up Eminem. But, I gotta admit that at first I didn't like this song. It took multiple listens for me to like this song. Eminem's flow goes great with the beat that Boi-1da provides.
8/10


9. No Love
This is a song that I loved the moment I heard it. I'm willing to admit that I don't like Lil Wayne whatsoever. But, he tends to sound decent when he's in a song with Eminem. The only thing that would have made this song perfect is if it didn't have Lil Wayne in it. Once again, I loved the beat that Just Blaze brought to the table. The way Eminem flowed with the beat, I wish he would have had 2 or 3 verses.
9/10


10. Space Bound
This is one of my favorite songs on Recovery. This song completely caught me off guard, didn't expect a love song based on the title. If I didn't know that Jim Jonsin produced this song before hand, I wouldn't of known he produced this song. It doesn't sound like a beat that Jim Jonsin would do. It has a great beat, followed by great lyrics and great flow to go along with it. I see this becoming a future single, with a music video going along with it. I think it would have a great video to take the song to another level.
10/10


11. Cinderella Man
This song immediately reminds me of Till I Collapse, which is one of my favorite songs on The Eminem Show. Script Shepherd came up with a great beat for Eminem to rap on. This is a song that would hype you up big time for a big event. Eminem has a great flow that goes along with the beat pefect. Definitely one of my favorite songs on Recovery.
10/10


12. 25 To Life
4 great songs in a row, loved this song from the moment I heard it. My favorite song on Recovery is a tie between this song and Going Through Changes. The first time I heard this song, I thought for sure he was talking about Kim the whole time until the ending. It caught me off guard so much that I loved it. DJ Khalil came up with a great beat for the song, Eminem's flow goes perfect with the beat.
10/10


13. So Bad
I was surprised to find out that this was the only Dr. Dre produced song on Recovery. I was hoping to hear more songs produced by Dre. Even though I've been wanting to see Eminem and Dre do more serious work together. It seems like Eminem can only fool around when Dre produces a song. Relapse was an album full of Dre production, and not 1 serious song together. Despite everything I just said, I actually liked So Bad. The song is really catchy and could picture it as a future single.
8/10


14. Almost Famous
I love this song just for the fact that it sounds like it could have gone great in the Marshall Mathers LP, which is arguably his best album. This is another song that's one of my favorite on Recovery. DJ Khalil produces his 4th great beat on Recovery, he steals the show when it comes to production on Recovery. Love the beat, and Eminem's lyrics and flow goes perfect with it.
10/10


15. Love The Way You Lie
No matter how much this song has been played out, I still love it. This song is similar to me like Space Bound. I never thought that Eminem would ever do songs like this. But, unlike other people that I've read on this forum. I don't see it as Eminem selling out from the way he used to be. After listening to Relapse the year before, I wanted to hear a completely different album. He tried to resurrect with his old style on that albun, and I didn't like it much. I think LTWYL ranks up there with Eminem's best songs, it shows how much he has matured from the past.
10/10


16. You're Never Over
Eminem finally makes a tribute for Proof. I also think it was a fitting tribute, even though some people around here expected something deeper for a tribute. I loved the way it turned out, Just Blaze comes up with another great beat. I would like to see him and Eminem work on more songs together in the future. I've said this alot in this review, but this is one of my favorite songs on Recovery.
10/10


17. Untitled
All I have to say about this song is that it sounds like the old slim shady, which is always a good thing.
9/10


To finish off this review, I would like to say that I feel like Recovery is Eminem's most complete album to date.
Last edited by CLV22798 on Sep 11th, '10, 17:57, edited 1 time in total.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby Spirit92 » Sep 11th, '10, 11:35

My my,people are getting generous with the 10/10's these days. :zipped:

Even MMLP doesn't have 8x 10/10 songs IMHO,let alone Recovery...
Spirit92
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 253
Joined: Aug 3rd, '10, 13:58
Location: Slovenia

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby CLV22798 » Sep 11th, '10, 18:10

Spirit92 wrote:My my,people are getting generous with the 10/10's these days. :zipped:

Even MMLP doesn't have 8x 10/10 songs IMHO,let alone Recovery...



I agree that MMLP doesn't have 8x 10/10 songs. and that's why I think Recovery is the most complete album he's ever done. I'm not giving out 10/10 just to put it out there. All the songs I rated like that, I really believe they are great songs.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby Devil'sAdvocate » Sep 12th, '10, 21:43

ur such a dick

everythin a 8/9/10 WTF
The devil ain't on a level same as him!
User avatar
Devil'sAdvocate
BOSS
BOSS
 
Posts: 11019
Joined: Apr 11th, '10, 14:23
Location: Nozone
Gender: Male

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby CLV22798 » Sep 13th, '10, 01:37

Devil'sAdvocate wrote:ur such a dick

everythin a 8/9/10 WTF



Well, I gave On Fire and WTP 7/10. But, that's how good I think Recovery is. I think every other song is 8/9/10.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby .єddy » Sep 13th, '10, 03:42

Man, fuck this. :shakehead:
Image

So why in the world do I feel so alone
Nobody but me, I'm on my own
Is there anyone out there
Who feels the way I feel
That there is then let me in and let me know I'm not the only one.
User avatar
.єddy
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 218
Joined: Mar 13th, '10, 05:55

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby slimsoxshady » Sep 13th, '10, 17:55

some like Untitled, WTP, and WBD are ranked lower for me
but i do think Recovery as a solid 7 songs that deserve 10/10
Talkin 2 Myself
Going Through Changes
Not Afraid
Seduction
No Love
Love The Way You Lie
You're Never Over

thats tied with TES (White America, COMC, Square Dance, Soldier, Say Goodbye Hollywood, Sing For the Moment, Till I Collapse)
the low points like the 3 songs i mentioned earlier are lower than the low points of the first 3 albums tho...so when you take that into account, I'd say after 3+ months that Recovery = SSLP = MMLP = TES, with the two other albums standing much much lower
#ThankYouRapGod
User avatar
slimsoxshady
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 10162
Joined: Jan 3rd, '09, 05:01
Location: 850
Gender: Male

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby CLV22798 » Sep 13th, '10, 19:23

slimsoxshady wrote:some like Untitled, WTP, and WBD are ranked lower for me
but i do think Recovery as a solid 7 songs that deserve 10/10
Talkin 2 Myself
Going Through Changes
Not Afraid
Seduction
No Love
Love The Way You Lie
You're Never Over

thats tied with TES (White America, COMC, Square Dance, Soldier, Say Goodbye Hollywood, Sing For the Moment, Till I Collapse)
the low points like the 3 songs i mentioned earlier are lower than the low points of the first 3 albums tho...so when you take that into account, I'd say after 3+ months that Recovery = SSLP = MMLP = TES, with the two other albums standing much much lower



At least someone finally took the time to write something that wasn't just bashing my opinion. Only thing I don't agree with is that the "low" points are lower than the "low" points in the first 3 albums. Personally, I don't think Recovery has any low points. There's not one song I don't like in the album. Now, my favorite albums in order would be: Recovery, The Eminem Show, Marshall Mathers LP, Slim Shady LP. 4 straight out classics.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby momentisgolden » Nov 25th, '10, 15:43

I made this review two days before the album dropped listening to the bootleg version. Looking back, i could have changed my opinion but nwae....

The album has terrible hooks; lacks Slim shady Humour or shock factor of his early work; disses Relapse; has only one semi-good verse by a guest rapper while two Pop/R&B artists also feature. There is a song called Cinderella Man which has the song title incorporated Forty two times (42!!) in less than 5 minutes. He makes another reference to Mariah Carey and a man with cancer. The production and beats can become extremely irritating as Dr Dre has only one song he produced. The opening song quotes God. Eminem is a terrible singer!! U still reading this? Then welcome to the review of Eminem’s Brand new album Recovery. Here, is where the review starts...

Paragraph one is true. BUT, this is an album by Marshal Mathers. While slim shady and eminem flash here and there, Recovery is essentially about the man behind the characters. It has substance. With genius wordplay and passion, his verses are true to hip-hop roots but spinned in a weirdly entertaining way. Eminem has always said how much the game needs him and unmistakably backs it up.

On the song “Talking To Myself” he opens up his soul in an unprecedented and welcome honesty.
“Encore I was on drugs / Relapse I was flushing em out
I've got something to prove to fans / I feel like I let em down.”


Kobe provides a great hook and Em spits out the verses with the venom of his heydays. He didn’t let down. In fact, where it not for the corny, suck-up endin...
“Weezy keep ya head up/ T.I. keep ya head up/ Kanye...”


the song could have been a classic.

“I just wrote a bullshit hook in between two long ass verses... look/ This aint a song”

Is one of numerous funny punchlines in his next song “On fire”. What he does is rap and rap well. Pink features on the next one which contains the best surprise of the album. Following this a groovy song in the form of “WTP”; unreal sampling in “Going Through Changes” (strongly recommended); a chart topper in “Not Afraid”; as close to a love jam by Eminem as he can get in “SpaceBound”; a repeatable number in “Seduction”; a collabo with Weezy; a great paradox in “25 to Life” and a well executed cameo by Rihanna in “Love the way you lie.”

He closes it out with a moving eulogy to his best friend Proof in “You’re never over.” IMO, best song on the album.

Eminem apologises (understandably) for subpar releases. Here he re-discovers how to be personal with a passion unparalleled in a fast-spitting inspirational mode. On this evidence, whatever comes next can only “Elevate to new height(s)” he might “need two mics.” Hopefully it will be soon.

I hate doing numbers but here it goes 8.5/10
Image
No Apologies
User avatar
momentisgolden
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 379
Joined: Nov 7th, '10, 13:59
Location: Zimbabwe
Gender: Male

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby AJS » Dec 11th, '10, 21:26

i love recovery the beats i like em`s lyrics are top notch serious subject matter white trash party is a song me n my friends bump on the way to school or when we are drivin around cinderella mans my fav song on the album and other then some mixing flaws on on fire i love this album my favorite em album although i can listen to relapse straight through its not bad at all and encore is good also just gotta skip ass like that i like just lose it every now and then rain man is decent big weenie and 1st single have moments where they can be played em puts out quality and i can`t wait for his next release :D
AJS - O.T.B Entertainment
AJS
Closet Cleaner
Closet Cleaner
 
Posts: 92
Joined: Nov 14th, '10, 03:27
Location: North Carolina
Gender: Male

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby AshleyxEminem » Dec 12th, '10, 01:03

:confusion: You sure did give him a lot of prop for this album :sweating: It's good though. :y:

My opinion:

1. Cold Wind Blows - 7/10
2. Talkin' To Myself - 9/10
3. On Fire - 5-6/10
4. Won't Back Down - 4/10
5. WTP - 4-5/10
6. Going Through Changes 10/10
7. Not Afraid - 8-9/10
8. Seduction - 7-8/10
9. No Love - 7-8/10
10. Space Bound - 8/10
11. Cinderella Man - 4/10
12. 25 to Life - 10/10
13. So Bad - 6-7/10
14. Almost Famous - 5-6/10
15. Love The Way You Lie [minus the over-rated pop fans] - 7/10
16. You're Never Over - 10/10
(17.) Untitled - 7/10

Overall album - 8/10
:)
Last edited by AshleyxEminem on Dec 12th, '10, 01:15, edited 1 time in total.
Why am I fighting to live, if I'm just living to fight? Why am I trying to see, when there ain't nothing in sight? Why am I trying to give, when no one gives me a try? Why am I dieing to live; if I'm just living to die? Someone tell me why. -Tupac
User avatar
AshleyxEminem
Closet Cleaner
Closet Cleaner
 
Posts: 14
Joined: Dec 11th, '10, 07:13

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby Mahmoud48 » Dec 12th, '10, 01:11

AshleyxEminem wrote::confusion: You sure did give him a lot of prop for this album :sweating: It's good though. :y:

My opinion:

1. Cold Wind Blows - 7/10
2. Talkin' To Myself - 9/10
3. On Fire - 5-6/10
4. Won't Back Down - 4/10
5. WTP - 4-5/10
6. Going Through Changes 10/10
7. Not Afraid - 8-9/10
8. Seduction - 7-8/10
9. No Love - 7-8/10
10. Space Bound - 8/10
11. Cinderella Man - 3/10
12. 25 to Life - 10/10
13. So Bad - 6-7/10
14. Almost Famous - 5-6/10
15. Love The Way You Lie [minus the over-rated pop fans] - 7/10
16. You're Never Over - 10/10

Overall album - 7/10
:)

Cinderella man is 3/10
ur opinion is invalid
ODD FUTURE ASAP OVOXO BLACK HIPPY GOOD MUSIC
User avatar
Mahmoud48
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2508
Joined: Jul 17th, '10, 03:40
Gender: Male

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby AshleyxEminem » Dec 12th, '10, 01:16

Cinderella man is 3/10
ur opinion is invalid


:unsure: I found that song quite annoying.
Why am I fighting to live, if I'm just living to fight? Why am I trying to see, when there ain't nothing in sight? Why am I trying to give, when no one gives me a try? Why am I dieing to live; if I'm just living to die? Someone tell me why. -Tupac
User avatar
AshleyxEminem
Closet Cleaner
Closet Cleaner
 
Posts: 14
Joined: Dec 11th, '10, 07:13

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby slimshadylappin » Dec 13th, '10, 04:53

Cold Wind Blows: 7/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 9/10
On Fire: 8/10
Won’t Back Down: 7.5/10
W.T.P: 7/10
Going Through Changes: 10/10
Not Afraid: 9/10
Seduction: 7/10
No Love: 8.5/10
Space Bound: 9/10
Cinderella Man: 8/10
25 To Life: 9/10
So Bad: 6/10
Almost Famous: 9/10
Love The Way You Lie: 8/10
You’re Never Over: 8.5/10
Ridaz: 7/10
Session One: 8/10
"It seems I was seeing the same scene adopted, prevalent in different things with the witnesses indifferent to stop it" - Wasalu Jaco
User avatar
slimshadylappin
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 798
Joined: Nov 6th, '10, 18:03
Location: Why do u wanna know where I am. You stalker
Gender: Male

Re: My Recovery Review

Postby ShadyNarkoticz » Dec 13th, '10, 19:33

AshleyxEminem wrote:
Cinderella man is 3/10
ur opinion is invalid


:unsure: I found that song quite annoying.

And Almost Famous a 5.
And On Fire a 5
And WTP a 4.

I'm sorry but :facepalm
Image
"It is not about lyrics anymore. It's about a hot beat and a catchy hook."
User avatar
ShadyNarkoticz
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 927
Joined: May 3rd, '10, 05:46
Gender: Male

Next

Return to Shady Reviews



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users