SliK wrote:EminemBase there is no personal hatred from me towards you at all, I think you're a great poster.
Believe it or not I have seen most of Derren Brown's routines up until a few years ago. The problem I find (and I've already touched on this) is that he takes it SO FUCKING SERIOUSLY. This is the equivalent of fucking Twilight to me. It's all just praying on incredibly stupid and suggestible people. It's total trash but people take it so fucking seriously and swear its amazing. I find it incredibly boring to be honest. And honestly, way fucking cornier than sparkling vampires.
That said, I'm not watching any of your links. I know they'll just bore me like all "magic" does. May e when I get home from work/uni
He doesn't take it so seriously though...
That just shows me that you CAN'T have watched much of him at all.
He's actually one of the funniest magicians about...
And if you'd actually watch
this clip for example, you'd see that. He has an awesome sense of humour... there is no way you've watched his routines lmao, because if you really had, and even if you didn't find him funny... you'd know for sure that he constantly debunks, sometimes genuinely explains what he's doing and why, downplays his abilities, is self-deprecating and regularly takes the piss out of the perception of himself.
But when it comes to some routines - he is very serious, and he has to be... and I know this from performing certain things on people... every routine is... I mean, different routines require different presentation or tones to get people in to certain presumptions and just to give the actual tricks some 'feel' to them. And in the same way a battle rapper pretty much HAS to be a badass by default in his rhymes (I mean you can take the piss out of yourself like Em has too, but in general) - somebody performing a magic routine, in general, has to be commanding and controlling. Because obviously... magic is not scientifically testable, it relies on exploiting misdirection, timing, people's presumptions, gullibility, inability to see things you're untrained to see and many other factors... so he has to 'get into character' with some stuff in order for it to work how it does.
By "all magic", what magic are you referring to by chance? Could you name a magician or two which you've seen which bores you? As if it's any mainstream American magician... yeah, they bore me and most people who are seriously in to magic as well. They ruin it, cheapen it and try to make it something it's not... good magicians always downplay their abilities to heighten misdirection, where as people like Blaine and Angel genuinely want people to just think they're Jesus, and they're some of the worst performers I have ever seen. I'd barely even call them magic, so if you're referring to people like them... you'll have to do better than that, and you haven't seen enough to say 'all magic' lmao, because if that is what you mean... that's so far away from a good magician and good magic and different in tone and style it's unreal. It really is like Soulja Boy compared to Eminem, and somebody listening to Soulja Boy and Wayne and saying "all hip-hop is terrible, just listen to it...".
He is hilarious in his live show, and is constantly sarcastic, and even plays on the seriousness of, often playing it down, referrnig to what he does as "smug guesswork"... how is that taking it so seriously lmao... he actually views magic as a silly introverted boy's need to impress people, which it is at its root, and which is why he tries to make it more about an experience than just showing off.
PS. He also intentionally plays on smugness so that people want to catch him out more. Trying to catch out a magician is the easiest way for a magician to fool somebody... because when we think of catching someone out with a choice or this or that... we all pretty much do the same things. So if a magician can get somebody in that state... they watch harder but watch the wrong things, and then in offbeat moments when they relax from such intense watching, they provide almost total freedom in misdirection; and, people do the same things when trying to catch people out, so it makes them more predictable. It's things like this I find interesting about magic and which Derren does too, it's interesting I think psychologically... the manipulation factor, learning about how predictable certain things are and how you can exploit them to make something unreal look real...
I really don't know what you mean about him taking it so seriously though, in fact, if I had to credit him with one thing I'd say it would be taking the seriousness out of it, in terms of... GENUINELY just saying you're A MAGICIAN and refusing to ever go near the area of explanation or discussing technique with a spectator... he's the opposite of that, he constantly invites you in a game of cat-and-mouse with him, making it a constant battle between him and the spectator, but is always playing games and betting money and explaining some things, lying about others... inviting you to figure out which; he's made it real world rather than "look at me the mystical man with strange powers who you must admire and clap for as I do things I've practiced in a cave for 200 years", he speaks to people like how you do in real-life, he has a conversation. He takes the self-seriousness out of it.
And I feel bad for the insults since you were nice, I recant them lmao. Let's keep it civil then, but seriously just watch that ONE clip even, you'll see the real Derren there. His TV work is usually darker and more serious, but on-stage... he is thrilling. And what he does there is fairly simple but the way he dresses it up and presents it is just beautiful. And he's really funny and subtle.