#teamMMLP2>SSLP

[shadyblogger]

for the record i think bad guy, rap god, headlights and rhyme or reason are all good

How about Groundhog Day?

[CrashBand]

sslp is his best album tho and mmlp2 is no where near it.

brain damage, if i had, bonnie and clyde, rock bottom, still don't give a fuck are all contenders for his best song. (10/10s)

then it has other great songs like role model, bad meets evil, as the world turns, just don't give a fuck and i'm shady (8s-9.5s/10)

then my name is, guilty conscious and cum on everybody all have fantastic elements to them as well (7s-8.5s/10)

[CrashBand]

for the record i think bad guy, rap god, headlights and rhyme or reason are all good

How about Groundhog Day?

haven't listened to it enough. but it didn't entice me.

[slims]

Arsonist - blocking the fire hose where the nozzle is.
Go to hospitals. - Steal the blood that tests positive;
Take it home, pour it in a cup, and drink lots of it
Tryin' on your mother's clothes, tryna get these bras to fit,
When she comes home, I'm waiting in the closet with
A knife; hidin' so quiet, you'll pro'bly hear the faucet drip.
All my life I've been a foster kid,
So if I die an early death, - suicides gon' be the cause of it.

This would of been dope in the final version of that BME joint. XD

[Amadeo]

but i dont know why u'r so hasty to claim that he wasnt smoking weed much during his writing.

what were ur reasons for thinking that? (genuine question)

Because he's already said he wrote SSLP sober (GQ interview). He wrote TES sober, as I explained before.

There's no definitive proof he was sober writing the MMLP songs so I'm not discounting the possibility he wrote some while "buzzed." To think he wrote Stan while baked out of his mind is just ridiculous, though.

I think it's more likely he was smoking weed while writing Devil's Night with his D12 friends.

[EminemInsider]

but i dont know why u'r so hasty to claim that he wasnt smoking weed much during his writing.

what were ur reasons for thinking that? (genuine question)

Because he's already said he wrote SSLP sober (GQ interview). He wrote TES sober, as I explained before.

There's no definitive proof he was sober writing the MMLP songs so I'm not discounting the possibility he wrote some while "buzzed." To think he wrote Stan while baked out of his mind is just ridiculous, though.

I think it's more likely he was smoking weed while writing Devil's Night with his D12 friends.

There's a video on YT with Eminem and D12 sitting around smoking weed, and you can tell Eminem is nonfunctional there. When Eminem gets high, he's slow...the exact opposite of what he needs to write and record. Just one listen to Highinem and it's blatantly obvious that that version of him would not be able to write well.

[TranSlucEnt]

but i dont know why u'r so hasty to claim that he wasnt smoking weed much during his writing.

what were ur reasons for thinking that? (genuine question)

Because he's already said he wrote SSLP sober (GQ interview). He wrote TES sober, as I explained before.

There's no definitive proof he was sober writing the MMLP songs so I'm not discounting the possibility he wrote some while "buzzed." To think he wrote Stan while baked out of his mind is just ridiculous, though.

I think it's more likely he was smoking weed while writing Devil's Night with his D12 friends.

There's a video on YT with Eminem and D12 sitting around smoking weed, and you can tell Eminem is nonfunctional there. When Eminem gets high, he's slow...the exact opposite of what he needs to write and record. Just one listen to Highinem and it's blatantly obvious that that version of him would not be able to write well.

DONT FUCK WITH THE WITCH, MAN!

[shadyblogger]

but i dont know why u'r so hasty to claim that he wasnt smoking weed much during his writing.

what were ur reasons for thinking that? (genuine question)

Because he's already said he wrote SSLP sober (GQ interview). He wrote TES sober, as I explained before.

There's no definitive proof he was sober writing the MMLP songs so I'm not discounting the possibility he wrote some while "buzzed." To think he wrote Stan while baked out of his mind is just ridiculous, though.

I think it's more likely he was smoking weed while writing Devil's Night with his D12 friends.

There's a video on YT with Eminem and D12 sitting around smoking weed, and you can tell Eminem is nonfunctional there. When Eminem gets high, he's slow...the exact opposite of what he needs to write and record. Just one listen to Highinem and it's blatantly obvious that that version of him would not be able to write well.

Exactly. Makes sense

[Aquamarina]

Id have to give SSLP the edge although not by too large of a margin at all.. I know guys, I know, no shoulda, woulda, coulda, but replace STIW, So Far, and Asshole, with Baby, Groundhog Day, and Wicked Ways, and also throw Don't Front on the main track list and I think I'd definitely say MMLP2 >>> SSLP

LOL, you guys really dont know writing.

My bad i really enjoy the mmlp2 era dude.. if you read my post i said sslp is a better album, yet id prefer the changes i stated.. i don't know writing? did i say any song was written better than another? no.. just preference.. STIW and Asshole SUCK DICK. Asshole is the most unpleasing eminem song musically since Fack. I don't hate So Far, but I could do without it, I skip it most of the time.

[shadyblogger]

Id have to give SSLP the edge although not by too large of a margin at all.. I know guys, I know, no shoulda, woulda, coulda, but replace STIW, So Far, and Asshole, with Baby, Groundhog Day, and Wicked Ways, and also throw Don't Front on the main track list and I think I'd definitely say MMLP2 >>> SSLP

LOL, you guys really dont know writing.

My bad i really enjoy the mmlp2 era dude.. if you read my post i said sslp is a better album, yet id prefer the changes i stated.. i don't know writing? did i say any song was written better than another? no.. just preference.. STIW and Asshole SUCK DICK. Asshole is the most unpleasing eminem song musically since Fack. I don't hate So Far, but I could do without it, I skip it most of the time.

Asshole doesn't suck dick. Asshole is probably the most MMLP-esque song on the whole album.

[yoda you can call me]

Id have to give SSLP the edge although not by too large of a margin at all.. I know guys, I know, no shoulda, woulda, coulda, but replace STIW, So Far, and Asshole, with Baby, Groundhog Day, and Wicked Ways, and also throw Don't Front on the main track list and I think I'd definitely say MMLP2 >>> SSLP

LOL, you guys really dont know writing.

My bad i really enjoy the mmlp2 era dude.. if you read my post i said sslp is a better album, yet id prefer the changes i stated.. i don't know writing? did i say any song was written better than another? no.. just preference.. STIW and Asshole SUCK DICK. Asshole is the most unpleasing eminem song musically since Fack. I don't hate So Far, but I could do without it, I skip it most of the time.

Fack off

[Mr Evil]

C'mon son

[Drax207]

My bad i really enjoy the mmlp2 era dude.. if you read my post i said sslp is a better album, yet id prefer the changes i stated.. i don't know writing? did i say any song was written better than another? no.. just preference.. STIW and Asshole SUCK DICK. Asshole is the most unpleasing eminem song musically since Fack. I don't hate So Far, but I could do without it, I skip it most of the time.

My god, fuck you

[CrashBand]

Because he's already said he wrote SSLP sober (GQ interview). He wrote TES sober, as I explained before.

if he said that, there isn't even an argument.

To think he wrote Stan while baked out of his mind is just ridiculous, though.

disagree with this. obviously be definition he wouldn't have been able to write it "baked out of his mind", but i disagree with what u'r implying. Sadistik's routine is wake up, smoke weed, drink coffee and do some shit towards his album.[/quote]

but yea, eminem could easily not be the type to function well on it. but one, or a few examples of when he's wasted isn't exactly conclusive.

[skc_]

None of his new shit touches the "big 3".
Also Relapse > mmlp2