Shady XV > MMLP2

[Mr Change]

I actually love the end of Shady XV

:kanyeshrug:

The voice ruins it for me

I'm not terribly fond of it either but I like the song

His voice as in....you know, Eminem's normal voice?

[shadyblogger]

It had a tone to it that was a tad bit annoying. Kinda like how some ppl found Em's SSLP voice to be annoying. It wasn't a big deal or anything tho

[Hopsinshadie]

Shady XV. You guys who picked MMLP 2 are lame. Shady 15 goes hard. Shady 15 is real, true hip hop. Boy you guys are being lame. You rather listen to ''So Much Better'' over ''Vegas'' or ''Right For me?''

[Jaba]

Shady XV. You guys who picked MMLP 2 are lame. Shady 15 goes hard. Shady 15 is real, true hip hop. Boy you guys are being lame. You rather listen to ''So Much Better'' over ''Vegas'' or ''Right For me?''

What are you 12?



lmao at myself almost replying to this seriously

[Nostradomus]

I think Shady XV is incredibly dope, but MMLP2 has too many gems.

Bad Guy, Evil Twin, Legacy are all Top 20 Em songs of ALL TIME
Nothing on Shady XV holds a candle to these three

Not to mention Rhyme or Reason is gold

[csw621]

Legacy is arguably a top 1 song. Schemes for fucking decades

[shadyblogger]

Legacy da GOAT

[shadyblogger]

Ems verse on PK is godly like damn. Probably one of my fav verses by Ems post comeback

It really is Glad to see that it's getting a lot of appreciation. It's so fucking genius and well done

[Whitefox]

His voice as in....you know, Eminem's normal voice?

Well, I dont know how to explain my feelings about this voice. I've just listened to Shady XV once again. I pretty much understand that it tended to be annoying like Blogs McGooch said, but it seems a bit forced to me, not natural Slim Shady's annoying voice, you know. Something like that lol. I got the same problem with the beginning of his PK verse, not the whole verse, just first 3-4 lines.

[Kill You]

I feel like some songs would have made MMLP2 much better. I can't say for sure which project is better but I will say Shady XV has better production and feels more like "Eminem."

[Jaba]

I hope Eminem produces more songs on his next solo album. Loving his beats.

SHADYXV is amazing

[csw621]

Some of you saying he doesn't sound like himself need to go listen to his bassmint and soul intent shit.

[boonim]

His skill level seems to have gone a step up on Shady XV -- with his flows and wordplay and I like that he's trying new stuff (Twisted!). But in terms of song writing, MMLP2 is superior. Songs like Bad Guy, RoR, Legacy, Asshole, Brainless, STIW (yes, I love it), Headlights, So Far, Love Game, Evil Twin -- all were conceptually and personally (except Love Game) meaningful and executed very well. The personal songs on a Shady XV are not as impactful as on MMLP2 -- couple of songs there actually made cry when I first heard them. Shady XV is more a lyrical display. Conceptually, Right For Me is very cool. I enjoy the other songs for the demonstration of technical skill, humour and his ability to casually say disgusting and outrageous things. So, MMLP2 for me.

[XxachiganxX]

Surprised at the results. I chose ShadXV way >> MMLP2. Like Kill You said, this sounds way more "Eminem" ish.

[Ares]

I feel like some songs would have made MMLP2 much better. I can't say for sure which project is better but I will say Shady XV has better production and feels more like "Eminem."

MMLP2 is way better if you take out some tracks from it and put Fine Line, Vegas and Right For Me on it imo.